Australia: the mounting costs of the Cashless Debit Card

Last month, the Federal Parliament of Australia extended the trials of the Cashless Debit Card in the East Kimberley and Ceduna. This legislation also has the provision to introduce a third site to the trial, most likely Kalgoorlie Boulder in WA.

Why another trial was necessary is a mystery. In 2014 the government commissioned a comprehensive multi-year independent Evaluation into New Income Management in the Northern Territory. This review was conducted by leading academics from some of Australia’s top universities and provided conclusive evidence that compulsorily income management regime in the Northern Territory did not make a significant difference. Despite the evidence showing that income management does not meet its objects regardless of over AU$1 billion spent on it, Andrew Forrest’s Review of Aboriginal Training and Employment still recommended what he called the ‘Healthy Welfare Card. In 2015, plans to implement the Cashless Debit Card began.

The perusal of income management by governments continues to be a disturbing trend given the evidence mounting against income management including its latest iteration the Cashless Debit Card.

About the Card

The trials for the Cashless Debit Card began in early 2016 in both Ceduna (South Australia) and the East Kimberley (Western Australia). The card quarantines 80% of social security payments received by all working-age people (15–64 years) in the trial sites, attempting to restrict cash and purchases of alcohol, illegal drugs and gambling products. The Card compulsorily includes people receiving disability, parenting, carers, unemployed and youth allowance payments. People on the aged pension, on a veteran’s payment or earning a wage are not compulsorily included in the trial but can volunteer to take part.

Continuing issues with the Cashless Debit Card

The trial disproportionately targets Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples despite the government stating that the CDC is for both Indigenous and non-Indigenous welfare recipients. These claims are disingenuous seeing the CDC was first proposed as a key recommendation in mining billionaire Andrew Forrest’s Review of Indigenous Training and Employment.

The trial has increased hardship in people’s lives, not only because of the disorganised and ill-conceived implementation of the experiment, but also because of the very design of the trial. People are being compulsory included because there is an assumption that they engage in problematic behaviours such as the overconsumption of alcohol, gambling or use illegal drugs. The reality is that most people forced onto the card instead struggle with poverty compounded by a number of factors, including trying to survive in remote circumstances with chronically precarious employment prospects.

Being put on the card has made people’s lives harder because limiting cash restricts people’s ability to undertake day to day activities to help their family’s wellbeing – from getting second hand goods, paying for transport and buying gifts. This hardship is reflected in the ORIMA final evaluation where 32% said that their lives were worse since being on the card and only 23% said that their lives were better. Further, 48% of participants on the card reported that the card does not help them look after their children better. These adverse impacts are concerning as recently completed research published by the ARC Centre of Excellence; the Life Course Centre, examining income management programs in the Northern Territory, actually shows causation with negative impacts on children, including a reduction in birth weight and school attendance. The researchers suggest several possible explanations for the reduction of birth weight, including how income management increased stress on mothers, disrupted existing financial arrangements within the household, and created confusion as to how to access funds.

Getting the assumptions wrong has been dangerous, pushing already vulnerable people into even more vulnerable situations. Medical specialists have raised concerns with the CDC being used to treat addiction. The $1.6 million in funding for ‘wrap around services’ have not been provided in a timely fashion. Both crime and domestic assaults increased under the card in the EK. Superintendent Adams told the Senate Inquiry that in the 12 months to 30 June 2016, there were 319 domestic assaults in Kununurra, but in the 12 months to 30 June 2017 (and the time of the trial), this figure had increased to 508. Human rights breaches continue to be a concern, most overlooked by the Human Rights Joint Committee commentary on the Bill.

The evidence the Government has relied on is flawed. The ORIMA interim and final evaluations were both used as a key plank in the ‘evidence’ used by the government to justify trial extensions. Both evaluations have been severely criticised as being methodologically and analytically flawed; from the way interviews were conducted, to having no base line to test government claims of success, through to an over-emphasis on anecdotal improvements and discarding important issues such as the increase in crime and domestic violence.

Claims of community representation and consultation. The decision to implement the Card was not a community decision that represents the region’s diverse interests or population. Some people have more say than others. For example, the Miriuwung Gajerrong Corporation noted that, although the ‘Department of Social Services (DSS) states that the Cashless Debit Card program was co-designed with local leaders in Kununurra … in reality, only four local leaders were consulted in relation to the introduction of the CDC in Kununurra’. Consultations themselves have not been about co-design, but have been tokenistic in order to convince people to support the card.

Where are the jobs anyway? In a perverse twist, as the only way people can get themselves off the trial, is to get a job. Yet in both Ceduna and the East Kimberley, the biggest cause of unemployment is the lack of formal, dignified and secure jobs. Linking to unemployment, some people included in the trial are also subjected to the punitive Community Development Program (CDP), further compounding poverty because of inducing high breaching rates.

Even if a few people support the card, we must ask at what cost? Many more have suffered material and emotional hardship, the community has been fractioned through such heavy-handed intervention, and the AU$25 million spend on the trial has demonstrated no credible evidence of sufficient benefit to justify ongoing roll out. That the Cashless Debit Card continues to be pursued by government and corporate elite exposes its dogged obsession with implementing neo-colonial and punitive policy for some economic and political gain at the expense of vulnerable people.

Dr Elise Klein is a lecturer in Development Studies at the University of Melbourne.

Article paru dans Pdg no 167

D’autres articles au sujet de l’Australie


Un commentaire

  1. S128 Indonesian Cockfighting Site

    Gambling games that are very attached to the hearts of Indonesian individuals are known as s128
    cockfight gambling. Looking from Indonesia’s historical record,
    cockfighting games have existed even since the
    days of the kingdom. This activity is not just entertainment but is usually also a part of a tradition passed down through generations
    of Indonesian ancestors.

    Regrettably, although this activity will be a cultural heritage associated with thousands of years, the particular Indonesian government does not really discriminate in enforcing the law until finally it is very difficult
    to find a spot to play cockfighting in Philippines.

    Fortunately technology invented the particular internet because in typically the modern era like you can now again access exciting online games
    through an internet connection. Enough using the capital regarding electronic devices for example notebooks, computers or smartphones linked to the internet, you can immediately
    enjoy typically the excitement of playing.

    Presently there are indeed many internet gambling sites that provide similar gives on the internet, but
    however not all of these sites can be reliable. Only a handful
    regarding sites have the ability to provide expert services
    which can be worthy of being obtained by customers as provided by the city of S128 Sabung Poultry.

    S1288 or better called S128 has been present for many years serving every enthusiast of online
    game cockfight gambling throughout Asia, actually
    the world. Hundreds of individuals are connected every week in order
    to enjoy every match that is presented and you could watch the match directly through
    the particular available live streaming.

    Right now there are many interesting characteristics that are
    owned by s128 as the finest chicken gambling bookie within Asia.

    Listed below are interesting characteristics that you should know:

    Live buffering!
    The first advantage you will get from playing cockfighting is the availability of live streaming chicken battles
    that are served in HD or even high definition quality.

    It appears to be very clear so that a person won’t miss a solitary bit of excitement employing S128 as your
    online gambling partner.

    Various competitions are available
    There are several tournaments that you take portion in all the time
    so simply no need to be afraid you will not get a sport because
    with s128 chicken matches will almost always be present
    every single day and you could take pleasure in the range of games you would like.

    Attractive Bonuses and Special offers
    Customer comfort is the top priority for us.
    As a result, this site has supplied many interesting bonuses
    in addition to promos that you may follow as an official member.
    These bonuses plus promos are given as thanks from s128 to customers for choosing all of them as partners to play online gambling.

    How to be able to Play Chicken Gambling about S128
    All you require to do first prior to starting the game will be to register yourself since a member on the particular Betberry site.
    It’s easy, visit the official Betberry website and enter the sign up
    menu. Complete the registration process
    and you will immediately get a user ID plus password that you will certainly later use
    to log into the game.

Laisser un commentaire

Votre adresse e-mail ne sera pas publiée.